Logical Reasoning Questions for CLAT | QB Set 107 [Strengthen/Weaken/Assumption]

Passage

Schools should ban students from using smartphones throughout the school day, except where a device is required for a documented medical need. Supporters of such a rule argue that smartphones are not merely another classroom distraction. Unlike an occasional conversation or a passing noise, they provide a continuous stream of messages, videos, games and notifications designed to attract attention. Even when students do not actively use their phones, knowing that a message may be waiting can divide their attention.

There is some evidence supporting restrictions. Research has found that student performance can improve after schools introduce mobile-phone bans, with some studies suggesting that the benefits may be particularly significant for previously lower-achieving students. Other research indicates that unrestricted smartphone use during lessons may reduce learning compared with situations in which smartphones are prohibited. 

Critics, however, argue that banning smartphones confuses correlation with causation. Schools that enforce strict phone rules may also have stronger discipline, more involved teachers or better academic systems. Moreover, smartphones can serve legitimate purposes: students may use them to research information, access educational applications or communicate with family members in emergencies. A ban may therefore remove useful technology without addressing the deeper reasons why some students struggle to concentrate.

These objections justify carefully designed exceptions, but they do not defeat the case for a general restriction. Schools routinely limit activities that have legitimate uses when unrestricted access interferes with their primary educational purpose. More importantly, allowing individual students to decide when smartphone use becomes distracting assumes that adolescents can consistently resist applications specifically designed to capture and retain attention.

Still, banning phones should not be treated as a guaranteed method of improving academic achievement. Recent research has found that although strict restrictions can substantially reduce in-school phone use, average improvements in test scores may be small or even absent in some settings. The strongest justification for a school-day ban is therefore narrower: if smartphones create a persistent and avoidable source of distraction, schools are justified in removing that distraction even if doing so does not automatically produce higher examination scores.

Questions

1. Which of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the passage?

(A) Smartphone bans inevitably improve students’ examination scores.
(B) Smartphones have no legitimate educational purpose in schools.
(C) Schools are justified in generally restricting smartphones because they create an avoidable source of distraction.
(D) Students who perform poorly academically are distracted mainly by smartphones.

2. The author’s argument that students should not individually decide when smartphone use becomes distracting most strongly depends on which assumption?

(A) Most adolescents own more than one digital device.
(B) Students cannot always accurately regulate their own smartphone use when applications compete for their attention.
(C) Teachers are better at using smartphones than students are.
(D) Educational applications are generally ineffective.

3. Which of the following, if established, would MOST strengthen the author’s argument for a general smartphone restriction?

(A) Students at schools with phone bans report that they dislike having to store their devices during the day.

(B) Many teachers occasionally use their own smartphones while preparing lessons.

(C) A controlled study finds that students randomly assigned to phone-free classrooms remain focused for longer and interrupt lessons less often than otherwise similar students allowed unrestricted phone access.

(D) Some educational applications are available only on smartphones.

4. Which of the following would MOST weaken the author’s central reasoning?

(A) A large controlled study finds that removing smartphones does not reduce classroom distraction because students immediately shift their attention to laptops, conversations and other distractions at approximately the same rate.

(B) Some parents prefer being able to contact their children directly during lunch breaks.

(C) Certain students use smartphones for dictionaries and calculators.

(D) Smartphone bans require teachers to spend some time explaining the rules.

5. Suppose a study finds that schools introducing smartphone bans experience no improvement in examination scores but show a substantial reduction in lesson interruptions and off-task behaviour. How would this evidence affect the argument in the passage?

(A) It would contradict the argument because the passage requires examination scores to improve.

(B) It would largely support the author’s final justification for smartphone restrictions.

(C) It would prove that smartphones have no educational value.

(D) It would weaken the argument because behavioural improvements are irrelevant to education.

6. Which of the following best identifies a potential flaw that the author expressly acknowledges in arguments based only on schools that introduced phone bans?

(A) They may assume that all students use smartphones for identical purposes.

(B) They may ignore the possibility that schools imposing bans differ in other ways that also influence academic performance.

(C) They assume that smartphones did not exist before academic performance declined.

(D) They compare smartphones with technologies that are completely different from them.

Answer Key

1. C
2. B
3. C
4. A
5. B
6. B

Detailed Explanations

1. Correct Answer: (C)

The author’s ultimate position is deliberately narrower than the claim that banning phones necessarily raises marks. The final paragraph states that even where academic gains are uncertain, schools may still be justified in removing smartphones because they represent a persistent and avoidable distraction.

Therefore, (C) captures the conclusion.

  • (A) is too strong. The passage expressly says that bans should not be treated as a guaranteed way to improve academic achievement.
  • (B) contradicts the passage, which recognises legitimate educational uses.
  • (D) wrongly treats smartphones as the primary cause of poor achievement.

2. Correct Answer: (B)

The relevant reasoning is:

Students should not simply be allowed to decide for themselves when smartphone use becomes distracting because applications are designed to capture attention.

For this reasoning to work, the author must assume that students’ ability to regulate their own use is not always reliable when faced with these attention-grabbing features.

Therefore, (B) is necessary.

The argument does not require multiple-device ownership, teacher superiority or the ineffectiveness of educational apps.

3. Correct Answer: (C)

The author’s central concern is that smartphones create avoidable distraction. A controlled study demonstrating that otherwise comparable students are more focused and interrupt lessons less when phones are removed directly supports the proposed causal relationship:

Removing smartphones → less distraction.

Therefore, (C) strongly strengthens the argument.

Option (A) concerns popularity, not effectiveness. Option (B) says little about student distraction. Option (D) actually highlights a benefit of smartphones and therefore does not strengthen the case for general restriction.

4. Correct Answer: (A)

The author’s case depends significantly on the idea that removing smartphones will remove a meaningful source of distraction.

Suppose students simply replace phones with other distractions and the overall amount of distraction remains approximately unchanged. The proposed benefit of removing phones would become much weaker.

Thus, (A) attacks the causal mechanism underlying the argument.

Options (B), (C) and (D) identify inconveniences or benefits but do not undermine the central claim nearly as seriously.

5. Correct Answer: (B)

The final paragraph carefully separates two propositions:

Proposition 1: Phone bans may increase examination scores.

Proposition 2: Phone restrictions can still be justified if they meaningfully reduce avoidable classroom distraction.

The hypothetical evidence rejects strong claims about higher scores but confirms reduced interruptions and off-task behaviour.

That evidence therefore fits the author’s narrower final argument particularly well, making (B) correct.

6. Correct Answer: (B)

The passage specifically raises the possibility that schools implementing strict phone rules may also have:

  • stronger discipline,
  • more involved teachers; or
  • better academic systems.

Therefore, if those schools subsequently perform better, it may be difficult to determine whether the phone ban itself caused the improvement.

This is a classic confounding-variable problem. Option (B) accurately describes it.

The other options identify issues that the passage neither relies upon nor expressly acknowledges as the central methodological weakness.


Calling all law aspirants!

Are you exhausted from constantly searching for study materials and question banks? Worry not!

With over 15,000 students already engaged, you definitely don't want to be left out.

Become a member of the most vibrant law aspirants community out there!

It’s FREE! Hurry!

Join our WhatsApp Groups (Click Here) and Telegram Channel (Click Here) today, and receive instant notifications.

More on CLATBuddy

Looking for More CLAT Preparation Resources?

Explore question banks, notes, current affairs, preparation guides and courses available on CLATBuddy.

More Resources for Your CLAT Preparation
Explore More →
CLAT Buddy
CLAT Buddy