Legal Reasoning Questions for CLAT | QB Set 98 [One Nation, One Election and Constitutional Questions]

TOPIC: One Nation, One Election and Constitutional Questions

Passage

India’s Constitution ordinarily gives the Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies a term of five years, unless they are dissolved earlier. This arrangement means that elections may occur at different times when governments lose their majority or legislatures are prematurely dissolved. The proposal popularly called “One Nation, One Election” seeks to synchronise elections to the Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies. The Constitution (One Hundred and Twenty-Ninth Amendment) Bill, 2024 was introduced for this purpose and, as of November 2026, remains under examination by a Joint Parliamentary Committee; it has not yet become law. 

Under the proposed framework, a new Article 82A would permit the President to issue a notification on the date of the first sitting of the Lok Sabha following a general election. This would become the “appointed date”. State Assemblies constituted after that date would not necessarily receive an independent five-year term. Instead, their terms would end when the full term of that Lok Sabha ends, enabling subsequent Lok Sabha and Assembly elections to be held simultaneously. 

The proposal also deals with premature dissolution. If the Lok Sabha or a State Assembly is dissolved before completing its full term, a fresh election would still be held. However, the newly elected House would ordinarily continue only for the remainder of the original five-year cycle, rather than receiving a fresh five-year term. Thus, if an Assembly falls with only eighteen months remaining in the common cycle, the Assembly elected afterwards would normally serve only those eighteen months. This mechanism is intended to prevent an early dissolution from permanently disturbing synchronisation. 

A further provision concerns situations where simultaneous polling in a particular State cannot be conducted. If the Election Commission forms that opinion, it may recommend that the President permit the State election to be held later. Even then, the delayed Assembly’s term would end with the Lok Sabha elected during the corresponding simultaneous-election cycle. The Bill does not presently prescribe a specific maximum period for such postponement, which has raised constitutional concerns about a State potentially remaining without an elected Assembly for some period. 

The proposal therefore raises broader questions about representative government and federalism. Parliament possesses the power to amend the Constitution, but constitutional amendments remain subject to the basic structure doctrine: Parliament cannot destroy fundamental constitutional features such as democracy or federalism. Consequently, synchronising elections is not automatically unconstitutional merely because State terms are altered. The constitutional question would depend upon whether the resulting arrangement merely restructures election timing or substantially damages foundational constitutional principles.

Questions

Question 1

Which of the following most accurately states the governing principle under the proposed simultaneous-election framework?

(A) Every Lok Sabha and State Assembly must always complete exactly five years, irrespective of premature dissolution.
(B) Once simultaneous elections begin, premature dissolution of any legislature is constitutionally prohibited.
(C) A legislature elected following premature dissolution may serve only the remaining portion of the common electoral cycle.
(D) State Assemblies may be dissolved only when the Lok Sabha is simultaneously dissolved.

Answer: (C)

Explanation: The proposal preserves the possibility of premature dissolution but prevents it from permanently disturbing the common cycle. A legislature elected after such dissolution normally serves only the remainder of the original five-year cycle. Therefore, option (C) correctly states the principle.

Question 2

Assume simultaneous elections were held in 2034 and the common five-year cycle is scheduled to end in 2039. In 2037, the government of State X loses its majority. No alternative government can be formed and the State Assembly is dissolved. Fresh elections are conducted immediately. The winning party argues that the newly elected Assembly must receive a fresh five-year term ending in 2042.

Under the proposed framework, which result is most appropriate?

(A) The Assembly should continue until 2042 because every general election creates a fresh five-year term.
(B) The Assembly should ordinarily continue only until 2039.
(C) No election may be conducted until the simultaneous elections of 2039.
(D) The Assembly can remain in office beyond 2039 if the Election Commission approves.

Answer: (B)

Explanation:
Rule: An Assembly elected after premature dissolution receives only the remainder of the common five-year cycle.
Relevant Facts: State X was dissolved in 2037, while the synchronised cycle ends in 2039.
Application: The fresh election does not restart the five-year clock. The new Assembly fills the remaining period so that its next election can again coincide with the Lok Sabha election.
Conclusion: The Assembly ordinarily serves only until 2039. Hence, (B) is correct.

Question 3

Suppose the President issues the constitutionally permitted notification establishing the appointed date. State Y conducts an Assembly election two years later. Under the ordinary constitutional rule, its Assembly would have continued for five years. However, the full term of the relevant Lok Sabha expires three years after State Y’s election.

What follows under the proposed system?

(A) State Y’s Assembly must continue for five full years because its election occurred after the appointed date.
(B) State Y’s Assembly ends when the Lok Sabha’s full term ends, even though it has served only three years.
(C) State Y may choose whether to participate in simultaneous elections.
(D) The Lok Sabha’s term must be extended until State Y completes five years.

Answer: (B)

Explanation:
Rule: State Assemblies constituted after the appointed date and before expiry of the relevant Lok Sabha’s full term are aligned with that Lok Sabha’s electoral cycle.
Relevant Facts: State Y was elected after the appointed date and has three years remaining when the Lok Sabha’s term ends.
Application: Its independent five-year term is curtailed for synchronisation.
Conclusion: The Assembly ends with the Lok Sabha’s term. Therefore, (B) is correct.

Question 4

Assume Parliament modifies the proposed rule. The modified provision states: “Whenever a legislature is prematurely dissolved, the House elected thereafter shall receive a fresh five-year term.” All other provisions requiring simultaneous elections remain unchanged.

Which consequence most directly follows?

(A) Maintaining permanent synchronisation would become more difficult because premature dissolution could create a new electoral cycle.
(B) Premature dissolution would automatically become unconstitutional.
(C) The Election Commission would acquire the power to dissolve other Assemblies.
(D) Every State election would necessarily have to be postponed until the next Lok Sabha election.

Answer: (A)

Explanation:
Rule: The original proposal preserves synchronisation by limiting a replacement House to the remaining portion of the common cycle.
Relevant Facts: The modified rule instead grants every newly elected legislature a fresh five-year term.
Application: If one Assembly falls midway through the cycle, its new five-year term could end several years after the Lok Sabha’s term, recreating separate election schedules.
Conclusion: Permanent synchronisation becomes harder to maintain. Hence, (A) is correct.

Question 5

During a simultaneous election, severe flooding makes polling throughout State Z temporarily impossible. The Election Commission concludes that the State Assembly election cannot be conducted with the Lok Sabha election and recommends postponement. The President accepts the recommendation.

Which statement best reflects the proposed framework?

(A) Postponement is impossible because every State must vote on exactly the same date.
(B) The election may be held later, but the resulting Assembly would still be aligned with the same Lok Sabha cycle.
(C) A postponed Assembly automatically receives five years beginning from its later election date.
(D) Postponement automatically extends the outgoing Assembly until polling takes place.

Answer: (B)

Explanation:
Rule: The Election Commission may recommend that a particular State election be conducted later where simultaneous polling cannot be held. A delayed Assembly nevertheless remains tied to the corresponding Lok Sabha cycle.
Relevant Facts: Flooding prevents polling in State Z and the President acts upon the Commission’s recommendation.
Application: This is the contemplated exception to simultaneous polling. It does not create a separate five-year electoral cycle for State Z.
Conclusion: Option (B) is correct.


Question 6

A constitutional amendment implementing simultaneous elections is challenged solely on the ground that shortening the terms of some State Assemblies necessarily violates the Constitution because every Assembly has an absolute right to complete five years.

Which is the strongest inference from the passage?

(A) The challenge must succeed because State Assemblies can never have their terms altered by constitutional amendment.
(B) The challenge must fail because constitutional amendments can never be reviewed by courts.
(C) Curtailment of Assembly terms is not by itself decisive; the deeper question is whether the amendment damages a feature such as democracy or federalism forming part of the Constitution’s basic structure.
(D) The challenge succeeds whenever even one State legislature objects to simultaneous elections.

Answer: (C)

Explanation:
Rule: Parliament may amend the Constitution, but its amendment power cannot destroy the Constitution’s basic structure.
Relevant Facts: The challenge relies only on the proposition that shortening Assembly terms is automatically unconstitutional.
Application: The passage does not treat every alteration of legislative tenure as prohibited. The constitutional enquiry instead concerns whether the overall arrangement substantially damages foundational principles such as democracy or federalism.
Conclusion: (C) is the strongest legal inference.

Answer Key

1. C
2. B
3. B
4. A
5. B
6. C


Calling all law aspirants!

Are you exhausted from constantly searching for study materials and question banks? Worry not!

With over 15,000 students already engaged, you definitely don't want to be left out.

Become a member of the most vibrant law aspirants community out there!

It’s FREE! Hurry!

Join our WhatsApp Groups (Click Here) and Telegram Channel (Click Here) today, and receive instant notifications.

More on CLATBuddy

Looking for More CLAT Preparation Resources?

Explore question banks, notes, current affairs, preparation guides and courses available on CLATBuddy.

More Resources for Your CLAT Preparation
Explore More →
CLAT Buddy
CLAT Buddy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *