Legal Reasoning Questions for CLAT | QB Set 99 [Article 371A and Fundamental Rights]

Passage

The Constitution sometimes gives special protection to the customs and traditional practices of particular communities. Article 371A is one such provision. It provides special constitutional protection in Nagaland in matters including Naga customary law and procedure. However, this protection does not mean that every decision taken in the name of custom automatically becomes immune from constitutional scrutiny.

A custom or usage may, in certain circumstances, operate with the force of law. Article 13 of the Constitution requires rules having the force of law to remain consistent with fundamental rights. Therefore, where a customary rule substantially affects legal rights, liberty, equality or personal status, a court may examine whether that rule violates fundamental rights. Article 371A cannot be interpreted as granting customary institutions an unrestricted authority to impose any sanction merely because the sanction is described as traditional.

This principle becomes especially important where customary bodies impose measures such as social excommunication, restrictions on movement, interference with a person’s village identity or penalties upon family members who had no role in the original dispute. Such measures may affect the guarantees of equality under Article 14, freedoms protected by Article 19 and life and personal liberty under Article 21. A restriction on a person’s freedom to move throughout India cannot ordinarily be imposed merely by a non-governmental institution. Restrictions on this constitutional freedom must have lawful authority and satisfy constitutional requirements.

Another issue concerns judicial review of private bodies. Article 226 gives High Courts broad writ jurisdiction. A private association does not automatically escape this jurisdiction merely because it is not “State” within Article 12. The crucial question is the nature of the function performed and the consequences of the challenged action. If a private institution performs a public duty or public function, or if its decision has a substantial public-law element, a writ petition may be maintainable against it. Thus, an institution exercising pervasive authority over villagers and making decisions affecting village identity, movement or legally recognised interests may be subject to judicial review.

This does not mean that every customary decision is unconstitutional. Courts need not interfere merely because a practice is traditional or because an individual disagrees with it. A customary body may continue regulating genuinely customary matters within its lawful sphere. Judicial intervention becomes justified when its action crosses constitutional limits—for example, by arbitrarily depriving individuals of protected rights, imposing disproportionate restrictions, or punishing uninvolved family members.

Accordingly, constitutional protection of cultural autonomy and judicial protection of individual rights must operate together. Tradition is protected, but constitutional protection does not convert tradition into unlimited governmental power.

Questions

Question 1

A traditional village council in Nagaland resolves that all disputes concerning local festivals, ceremonies and customary dress will be decided according to long-established village customs. A resident challenges the resolution merely because she believes modern rules would be preferable. She does not allege discrimination, restriction of liberty or infringement of any other fundamental right.

Which of the following is the most appropriate conclusion?

(A) The resolution is automatically invalid because customary bodies cannot make binding decisions.

(B) The resolution is automatically invalid because Article 371A protects customs only against legislative action, not customary decisions.

(C) The resolution need not be invalid merely because it applies customary rules, provided it remains within the lawful customary sphere and does not violate constitutional rights.

(D) The resolution cannot be examined by any court because Article 371A completely excludes judicial review.

Question 2

Following a disagreement over the management of a village association, a customary council declares twelve members and their families socially excommunicated. They are prohibited from entering the village, identifying themselves with the village in official dealings and attending community ceremonies. The spouses and children of the twelve members were not involved in the dispute.

Applying the principles in the passage, which is the strongest legal conclusion?

(A) The sanctions are valid because Article 371A gives customary institutions complete authority over village membership.

(B) The sanctions are constitutionally questionable because they substantially affect protected rights and extend punishment to persons unconnected with the dispute.

(C) Only the restrictions imposed on children are questionable; all restrictions imposed on the twelve members are constitutionally protected.

(D) The sanctions are valid unless Parliament first passes legislation expressly prohibiting village excommunication.

Question 3

Assume the facts in Question 2 are changed. Instead of preventing anyone from entering the village or using a village identity, the council merely suspends the twelve members for three months from voting in the internal election of a voluntary cultural club. Membership of the club has no effect on government documents, movement, employment, public benefits or civil status.

Which fact most strongly weakens the case for intervention under Article 226?

(A) The council relies upon a customary practice.

(B) The affected persons disagree with the council’s interpretation of tradition.

(C) The decision appears confined to the internal affairs of a voluntary private association and has little or no public-law consequence.

(D) The suspension lasts for three months rather than permanently.

Question 4

Parliament hypothetically amends the Constitution to provide: “Any customary rule protected by Article 371A shall remain valid even if inconsistent with Articles 14, 19 or 21.”

For the purpose of this question, assume that the amendment is valid and must be applied exactly as written.

How would this modified rule affect the reasoning contained in the passage?

(A) Courts would still have to invalidate every Article 371A custom inconsistent with fundamental rights because Article 13 can never be displaced.

(B) Article 371A would cease to protect customary law altogether.

(C) Courts could review customary rules only if the affected persons were government employees.

(D) The passage’s principle that Article 371A customs must yield to Articles 14, 19 and 21 would no longer apply to the extent expressly excluded by the amendment.

Question 5

A private charitable association operates a community library. Its managing committee removes Ravi’s library membership because he repeatedly failed to return borrowed books. The association performs no statutory function, controls no governmental benefit and its decision does not affect Ravi’s movement, identity, employment or any legally recognised public entitlement.

Which principle from the passage is most relevant?

(A) Every decision of every private association is reviewable under Article 226.

(B) Article 226 ordinarily requires examination of whether the private body’s function or challenged action possesses a public-law element.

(C) Any disciplinary decision by a private body violates Article 21.

(D) Private associations become “State” under Article 12 whenever they regulate the conduct of their members.

Question 6

A traditional institution argues: “Our practices receive constitutional protection. Therefore, courts cannot examine any sanction that we describe as customary.”

Which of the following is the strongest inference from the passage?

(A) The argument is correct because cultural autonomy necessarily excludes fundamental-rights review.

(B) The argument is correct only when the sanction has existed for more than fifty years.

(C) The argument is incorrect because constitutional protection of custom does not amount to unrestricted authority, particularly where customary action substantially interferes with fundamental rights.

(D) The argument is incorrect because the Constitution gives no protection whatsoever to customary laws.

Answer Key

  1. (C)
  2. (B)
  3. (C)
  4. (D)
  5. (B)
  6. (C)

Detailed Explanations

Question 1 — Correct Answer: (C)

Rule: Article 371A protects Naga customary laws and practices, but this protection is not unlimited. Courts need not interfere with every customary decision; intervention becomes relevant when a customary action violates constitutional rights or otherwise crosses constitutional limits.

Relevant Facts: The council regulates festivals, ceremonies and customary dress. No discrimination, restriction of liberty or other fundamental-right violation has been alleged.

Application: The mere fact that a council applies traditional rules does not make its decision unconstitutional. The passage specifically distinguishes legitimate regulation of customary matters from sanctions that infringe protected rights.

Conclusion: Option (C) is correct.

Option (A) wrongly assumes customary bodies have no lawful decision-making role. Option (D) goes to the opposite extreme by treating Article 371A as completely excluding judicial review.

Question 2 — Correct Answer: (B)

Rule: A customary sanction may be constitutionally scrutinised where it affects equality, freedom of movement, liberty, identity or other protected interests. Imposing consequences upon family members who had no involvement in the underlying dispute further strengthens concerns of arbitrariness.

Relevant Facts: The members and their families are prevented from entering the village, using their village identity and participating in community life. Their spouses and children did not participate in the disagreement.

Application: These consequences extend far beyond an internal disciplinary measure. They affect movement, identity and uninvolved family members. Article 371A does not provide unrestricted power to impose such measures.

Conclusion: Option (B) is correct.

Option (A) incorrectly treats Article 371A as absolute. Option (D) is incorrect because constitutional scrutiny does not depend upon Parliament first legislating against the precise sanction.

Question 3 — Correct Answer: (C)

Rule: A writ against a private institution becomes more plausible when the institution performs a public function or when the challenged action has a substantial public-law element.

Relevant Facts: The changed decision concerns only voting in an internal voluntary cultural club. It does not affect movement, official identity, benefits, employment or civil status.

Application: The absence of consequences outside the organisation makes the dispute resemble an internal private-association matter rather than an exercise of authority carrying public-law consequences.

Conclusion: Option (C) is correct.

The temporary duration in Option (D) may affect proportionality, but the absence of a public-law element is much more significant for deciding whether Article 226 jurisdiction should be exercised.

Question 4 — Correct Answer: (D)

Rule: Questions involving a modified legal rule must be answered according to the modification stated in the question.

Relevant Facts: The hypothetical constitutional amendment expressly provides that protected Article 371A customs remain valid even when inconsistent with Articles 14, 19 or 21.

Application: The original passage proceeds on the opposite rule: constitutional protection of custom does not exempt such customs from fundamental-rights scrutiny. If the Constitution were expressly changed as stated, that part of the original reasoning could no longer operate within the area covered by the amendment.

Conclusion: Option (D) is correct.

Option (A) ignores the expressly modified constitutional rule.

Question 5 — Correct Answer: (B)

Rule: A private body is not automatically subject to writ jurisdiction merely because it makes decisions affecting its members. Courts examine whether it performs a public duty or whether the challenged action possesses a public-law element.

Relevant Facts: The association is an ordinary private charitable body. Ravi’s loss of library membership affects no governmental benefit, public status, movement or legally recognised public entitlement.

Application: The dispute appears to be a purely internal membership matter. The facts provide no strong indication that the association exercises public authority or that its disciplinary decision has public-law consequences.

Conclusion: Option (B) is correct.

Option (A) makes writ jurisdiction automatic, contrary to the passage. Option (D) incorrectly equates private regulation with becoming “State” under Article 12.

Question 6 — Correct Answer: (C)

Rule: Constitutional recognition of customary law does not create unlimited authority. A custom having significant legal consequences may still be examined for consistency with constitutional guarantees.

Relevant Facts: The institution claims that merely describing a sanction as customary prevents judicial review.

Application: This claim directly conflicts with the governing principle in the passage. Article 371A protects customary institutions and practices, but does not create a blanket exclusion from constitutional scrutiny.

Conclusion: Option (C) is correct.

Option (A) incorrectly treats cultural protection as absolute. Option (D) is also incorrect because the passage recognises that Article 371A does provide genuine constitutional protection to Naga customary laws; the protection is simply not unlimited.


Calling all law aspirants!

Are you exhausted from constantly searching for study materials and question banks? Worry not!

With over 15,000 students already engaged, you definitely don't want to be left out.

Become a member of the most vibrant law aspirants community out there!

It’s FREE! Hurry!

Join our WhatsApp Groups (Click Here) and Telegram Channel (Click Here) today, and receive instant notifications.

More on CLATBuddy

Looking for More CLAT Preparation Resources?

Explore question banks, notes, current affairs, preparation guides and courses available on CLATBuddy.

More Resources for Your CLAT Preparation
Explore More →
CLAT Buddy
CLAT Buddy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *