English Language Questions for CLAT | QB Set 57

Topic: Genetics, Evolution and Species Classification

Passage

For much of biological history, scientists classified species mainly by observing visible characteristics. If two groups of organisms looked sufficiently different, lived in different places or behaved differently, they were often assigned to separate species. Modern genetics has complicated this seemingly simple task. DNA analysis can reveal differences between populations that appear almost identical, while also showing surprising genetic similarities between organisms that look quite different.

This does not mean that appearance has become irrelevant. Rather, scientists increasingly recognise that no single method can answer every question about species identity. One widely used approach defines a species as a group of organisms capable of breeding with one another and producing fertile offspring. Yet even this definition has limitations. It cannot easily be applied to organisms that reproduce asexually, nor can scientists directly test whether two populations that lived thousands of years apart could have interbred.

Evolution adds another layer of complexity. Populations are not genetically fixed. Mutations introduce new genetic variations, while natural selection may make some variations more common when they improve survival or reproduction in a particular environment. Geographic separation can also reduce breeding between populations. Over many generations, separated populations may accumulate enough differences to become distinct species. But this process does not happen at a single, easily identifiable moment. There may be a long period during which two populations are different in some respects but still capable of exchanging genes.

Consider two populations of birds separated when a river changes its course. One population begins living in dense forest, while the other occupies open grassland. Forest birds with shorter wings may manoeuvre more effectively among trees, whereas grassland birds with longer wings may travel more efficiently across open spaces. If these traits are partly inherited, environmental pressures can gradually make the populations more distinct. Their songs, feeding habits and mating preferences may also change. Thousands of years later, scientists may disagree about whether the populations should be called separate species.

Such disagreement does not necessarily indicate weakness in science. Categories are tools humans create to describe patterns in nature, while evolution is a continuous process that does not always respect sharp boundaries. Genetic evidence has made classification more precise, but it has also exposed how complicated biological relationships can be. The challenge is therefore not merely to find the “correct” label for every organism, but to understand what different classifications reveal about ancestry, adaptation and evolutionary change.


Questions

1. Which of the following best expresses the central idea of the passage?

(A) Genetic evidence has made traditional methods of species classification completely unnecessary.
(B) Species classification is increasingly complex because evolutionary processes do not always produce clear biological boundaries.
(C) Scientists should classify species entirely on the basis of their ability to produce fertile offspring.
(D) Modern scientists disagree about species mainly because genetic research is unreliable.

2. What can most reasonably be inferred from the example of the two bird populations?

(A) Geographic separation alone immediately creates two different species.
(B) Differences in wing length necessarily prevent two bird populations from interbreeding.
(C) Different environments can gradually encourage inherited differences between separated populations.
(D) Behavioural differences are more important than genetic differences in determining species.

3. In the context of the passage, what does the statement that evolution “does not always respect sharp boundaries” most nearly suggest?

(A) Evolution frequently occurs without any genetic change.
(B) Biological change may occur gradually, making exact categories difficult to draw.
(C) Scientists should abandon the practice of classifying organisms.
(D) Natural selection operates differently from all other evolutionary processes.

4. Which of the following best describes the author’s attitude towards disagreement among scientists about species classification?

(A) Critical, because disagreement demonstrates that classification systems have failed.
(B) Concerned, because genetic evidence has made scientific conclusions less dependable.
(C) Indifferent, because species classification has little value in understanding evolution.
(D) Accepting, because disagreement can arise from the complexity and gradual nature of evolutionary change.

5. Which conclusion is most strongly supported by the passage?

(A) A useful system of biological classification may need to consider several kinds of evidence rather than depend upon one rigid test.
(B) Genetic similarity should always outweigh visible differences when organisms are classified.
(C) Organisms living in different environments will eventually become separate species.
(D) Species categories have no scientific value because they are created by humans.

Answer Key

1. (B)
2. (C)
3. (B)
4. (D)
5. (A)

Detailed Explanations

1. Correct Answer: (B)

The passage mainly argues that species classification is not always straightforward because evolution is gradual and biological populations may not fit neatly into fixed categories. The author discusses morphological evidence, reproductive ability, genetic information, geographic isolation and evolutionary change to demonstrate this complexity.

Option (A) is incorrect because the passage specifically states that appearance has not become irrelevant. Option (C) is too narrow because the reproductive definition itself has limitations. Option (D) reverses the author’s argument: genetic research has not been described as unreliable; instead, it has revealed additional biological complexity.

2. Correct Answer: (C)

The bird example illustrates how different environments may favour different inherited characteristics over generations. Shorter wings may benefit forest birds, while longer wings may benefit grassland birds. If such differences influence survival or reproduction and are inherited, they may become more common.

The example does not suggest that geographic separation instantly creates new species, making (A) incorrect. Nor does the passage say that wing differences necessarily prevent interbreeding, eliminating (B).

3. Correct Answer: (B)

The phrase “does not always respect sharp boundaries” emphasises the continuous nature of evolutionary change. Two populations may gradually become different while continuing to exchange genes for some time. Therefore, there may be no precise generation at which scientists can confidently declare that one species has suddenly become two.

Option (C) goes too far. The author does not reject classification; the passage instead presents classification as a useful tool whose limitations must be recognised.

4. Correct Answer: (D)

The author’s attitude is accepting and explanatory rather than critical. The passage explicitly states that disagreement “does not necessarily indicate weakness in science.” Scientists may reasonably disagree because evolution produces gradual changes that do not always correspond to clear categories.

Option (A) directly contradicts this position. Option (B) is also incorrect because the author regards genetic evidence as making classification more precise, even though it reveals additional complexity.

5. Correct Answer: (A)

The passage repeatedly demonstrates the limitations of relying upon any single test of species identity. Physical appearance, reproductive compatibility, genetics, behaviour and evolutionary history can all provide relevant information. The most defensible conclusion is therefore that scientists may need to consider several forms of evidence.

Option (B) is too absolute because the author never claims genetic evidence must always take priority. Option (C) incorrectly treats speciation as inevitable. Option (D) misrepresents the final paragraph: categories may be human-created tools, but they remain useful for understanding ancestry, adaptation and evolution.


Calling all law aspirants!

Are you exhausted from constantly searching for study materials and question banks? Worry not!

With over 15,000 students already engaged, you definitely don't want to be left out.

Become a member of the most vibrant law aspirants community out there!

It’s FREE! Hurry!

Join our WhatsApp Groups (Click Here) and Telegram Channel (Click Here) today, and receive instant notifications.

More on CLATBuddy

Looking for More CLAT Preparation Resources?

Explore question banks, notes, current affairs, preparation guides and courses available on CLATBuddy.

More Resources for Your CLAT Preparation
Explore More →
CLAT Buddy
CLAT Buddy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *