The writ of prohibition is a legal remedy that aims to prevent a lower court or tribunal from exceeding its jurisdiction or acting beyond its legal authority. It is a discretionary order issued by a higher court to prohibit the lower court or tribunal from proceeding with a particular case or taking a specific action.
The writ of prohibition plays a crucial role in maintaining the judicial system’s integrity and ensuring that legal proceedings are conducted within the bounds of the law.
Purpose of Prohibition
The primary purpose of the writ of prohibition is to prevent a lower court or tribunal from acting beyond its jurisdiction or violating established legal principles.
It is often sought when there is a concern that the lower court is improperly exercising its authority, engaging in biased behaviour, or acting ultra vires (beyond its legal powers).
Conditions for Issuance
To obtain the writ of prohibition, certain essential conditions must be met:
Jurisdictional Error
The petitioner must demonstrate that the lower court or tribunal has committed a jurisdictional error. This can include exceeding its legal authority, acting outside the scope of its jurisdiction, or violating established legal principles.
Lack of Alternative Remedies
The petitioner must show that no adequate alternative remedies are available to address the jurisdictional error or prevent further harm. Prohibition is typically sought when other remedies, such as appeals or review processes, are not effective or practical.
Substantial Injustice
The petitioner must establish that allowing the lower court or tribunal to continue its proceedings or actions would result in substantial injustice. This can include violating fundamental rights, denying a fair trial, or irreparable harm that cannot be adequately remedied through other means.
Preserving Judicial Integrity
The writ of prohibition plays a crucial role in preserving the integrity and fairness of the judicial system. By restraining lower courts from acting beyond their authority, it ensures that legal proceedings are conducted within the confines of the law and in accordance with established principles of justice. This protects individuals’ rights and maintains public confidence in the judicial process.
Scope and Limitations
The writ of prohibition has certain limitations and scope:
Limited to Jurisdictional Issues
Prohibition is primarily concerned with jurisdictional errors and legal authority. It does not apply to challenges against discretionary decisions or mistakes in applying the law.
Higher Court Discretion
Issuing the writ of prohibition is a discretionary power of the higher court. The court will consider the merits of the case and the potential for substantial injustice before deciding whether to grant the writ.
Writ of Prohibition and Writ of Certiorari
| Aspect | Writ of Prohibition | Writ of Certiorari |
| Purpose | Prevents lower courts from exceeding jurisdiction or acting beyond authority. | Reviews and corrects errors of law made by lower courts. |
| Nature | Prohibitory and preventive in nature. | Corrective and remedial in nature. |
| Jurisdictional Error | Addresses jurisdictional errors and acts beyond authority. | Addresses errors of law made by lower courts. |
| Applicability | Used during ongoing proceedings to halt or prevent further action. | Used after the conclusion of lower court proceedings. |
| Availability | Available before or during the proceedings in the lower court. | Available after the conclusion of the proceedings in the lower court. |
| Objective | Prevents injustice or violation of rights due to improper jurisdiction. | Corrects errors of law and ensures fairness and justice. |
| Parties Involved | Higher court issues the writ to the lower court or tribunal. | Higher court issues the writ to the lower court or tribunal. |
| Scope | Limited to jurisdictional issues and excess of authority. | Addresses errors of law, including procedural and substantive errors. |
| Discretion of the Court | Discretionary power of the higher court to issue the writ. | Discretionary power of the higher court to grant or deny the writ. |
| Effect on Lower Court | Prohibits the lower court from continuing proceedings or taking a specific action. | Orders the lower court to send the case records for review or correction. |
| Remedial Measures | Prevents further harm or injustice by stopping improper proceedings. | Corrects errors of law and ensures fairness in the legal process. |
Summary
The writ of prohibition is a vital legal remedy that ensures the proper exercise of jurisdiction and upholds the rule of law within the judicial system. By preventing lower courts or tribunals from exceeding their authority, it protects the rights of individuals and safeguards the integrity of legal proceedings.
Understanding the conditions and limitations for issuing the writ of prohibition is crucial for effectively utilizing this remedy to address jurisdictional errors and maintain a just and fair judicial system.
Note: Access complete CLAT Legal Reasoning notes here.
Calling all law aspirants!
Are you exhausted from constantly searching for study materials and question banks? Worry not!
With over 15,000 students already engaged, you definitely don't want to be left out.
Become a member of the most vibrant law aspirants community out there!
It’s FREE! Hurry!
Join our WhatsApp Groups (Click Here) and Telegram Channel (Click Here) today, and receive instant notifications.
